Navigating Pet Nutrition: Understanding AAFCO and Its Impact on Pet Food Regulations

Written by: 

Dr. Danielle Conway, DVM ACVIM Nutrition Board Eligible, CVA, VSMT  

Nutrition board-eligible veterinarian with extensive experience in integrative medicine and nutrition.  

Paw Prints


Understanding AAFCO and Pet Food Regulations

In the realm of pet nutrition, the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) plays a pivotal role, although it is often misunderstood. Let's explore who they are, their key functions, and what roles they play in the pet food industry.

Beagle dog eating dog food from a bowl

Introduction to AAFCO and Its Role in Pet Nutrition
Creating healthy and nutritious pet food requires adherence to specific standards to ensure that our furry friends receive all the necessary nutrients. Key to this process is understanding the roles played by major regulatory and advisory bodies such as the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), the European Pet Food Industry Federation, and the Nutrient Research Council.

Understanding Nutrient Standards and Sources
When developing pet food, it's crucial to refer to established standards for the required nutrients, which include proteins, fats, vitamins, and minerals. These standards are primarily set by AAFCO in the United States, which provides guidelines but not regulatory oversight.

AAFCO’s Role and Influence
Despite common misconceptions, AAFCO is not a regulatory agency but a voluntary organization that sets nutritional standards for pet food in the U.S. Its guidelines serve as a benchmark used by state and federal bodies to enforce pet food safety and quality.

Key Functions of AAFCO

Regulatory Oversight and Relationships
AAFCO collaborates with various government agencies like the FDA and USDA to shape the regulatory landscape of pet food safety and labeling, although it does not have regulatory authority itself.

Model Regulations and Standards
The organization develops model regulations that help harmonize the standards across different states, ensuring a consistent approach to pet food safety and labeling across the country.

Defining Ingredients and Nutritional Requirements
AAFCO also defines ingredients and sets minimum and maximum levels of nutrients required to meet the life stage needs of pets, ensuring balanced and nutritious pet food formulations.

Back of Premium Nutrition Dog Food with Ingredients and All Stages of Life label

Feeding Trials and Labeling Requirements
Feeding trials, conducted according to AAFCO guidelines, help determine if a pet food meets the necessary nutritional standards. AAFCO also sets comprehensive labeling guidelines that inform consumers about the contents and nutritional value of pet food.

AAFCO Feeding Trials

What is an AAFCO Feeding Trial?
Feeding trials are critical for assessing the nutritional adequacy of pet foods. These trials involve feeding the food to animals and closely monitoring their health and nutrition throughout the trial period.

Detailed Steps in AAFCO Feeding Trials
From selecting healthy animals to conducting thorough post-trial evaluations, AAFCO feeding trials are designed to rigorously test pet foods under controlled conditions to ensure they meet specified nutritional standards.

Benefits and Limitations of AAFCO Trials
While AAFCO trials test actual food consumption in pets, they are considered basic minimum standards. Additional tests, such as digestibility and bioavailability studies, are recommended to ensure a diet's quality and efficacy.

AAFCO feeding trial diagram

AAFCO and Industry Alignment

Criticism and Defense of AAFCO
AAFCO has faced criticism for its close ties with the pet food industry. However, it's important to recognize that while the organization advocates for industry standards, it also includes individuals deeply committed to animal health and nutrition.

Comparison with Other Nutritional Standards
Unlike the Nutrient Research Council, which bases its guidelines on ideal, often fresh ingredients, AAFCO provides more practical, industry-relevant standards that are regularly updated to reflect new research and trends.

The Importance of Going Beyond AAFCO

Adopting Higher Standards in Pet Food Production
While AAFCO sets foundational standards, many pet food manufacturers strive to exceed these guidelines to provide superior nutritional value and safety in their products, incorporating rigorous in-house testing and quality control measures. At ButcherBox For Pets, you can be sure they are taking the steps to deliver the highest standards of pet food. 

Final Thoughts
AAFCO plays a crucial role in setting the framework for pet food safety and nutrition in the U.S. By understanding and adhering to these guidelines, pet food manufacturers can ensure that their products are not only compliant but also high in quality, contributing to the overall health and well-being of pets.

Back to Pack Education & Resources