The simple 7-day transition plan

Think of transitioning your dog’s food like putting together the perfect puzzle. Each day, a new piece falls into place, and by day seven, their diet is complete and smoothly integrated into their daily routine. Our simple 10-day plan ensures a happy, healthy switch with no surprises.

Day 1 + 2: Start Small

Feed 3/4 old diet with 1/4 Premium Nutrition

Check-in: How's Your Dog Doing?

A few days into the transition is the perfect time to check how your dog is adjusting. Notice their appetite and watch for mild signs like gas or loose stools. If needed, it’s okay to slow down—reduce the new food and stick to the previous ratio for a few more days.

Every dog adjusts at their own pace, and taking it slow is perfectly normal. Patience is key, and your pup will get there with time!

Day 3 + 4: Half it

Mix half old diet and half Premium Nutrition

Day 5 +6: Almost there

Feed 3/4 Premium Nutrition with 1/4 old diet

Day 7: You did it!

Feed full serving of Premium Nutrition

The journey continues

Your dog’s transition is done, but the best is yet to come! Continue with Premium Nutrition for lasting health, happier days, and less hassle for you.

Common Transition Challenges
(and How to Solve Them)

It’s completely normal for dogs to need a little extra time adjusting to a new food, and minor challenges like loose stools or picky eating are common.

These symptoms don’t reflect the quality of the food or your efforts, so stay patient—this adjustment period is only temporary, and we have simple solutions to help.

Loose Stool or
Digestive Upset
One of the most common issues during a food transition is loose stool.

An easy remedy? Try adding a spoonful of canned pumpkin (not pumpkin pie filling) to their food. It’s full of natural fiber, which helps regulate digestion, and is available at most grocery stores.

Picky Eating or Food Refusal
If your dog seems hesitant to try their new food, try a light sprinkle of parmesan cheese or a bit of their favorite treat on top.

Often, this enticing addition is all they need to start eating. Patience is key—most dogs will come around with gentle encouragement.

The right choice for smooth transition

Our food’s high-quality ingredients make it easy on your dog’s digestive system, ensuring that your transition will be smooth and worry-free.

Whole, high-quality proteins like real chicken make digestion easier, minimizing gas and bloating.

Nutrient-dense ingredients such as quinoa, carrots, and green beans add fiber and essential vitamins, supporting a balanced gut for firmer stools.

Minimally processed, real ingredients retain natural nutrients, so they're gentler on your dog’s system, allowing for a smoother transition to their new diet.

What's all the bark about?

I'm convinced this food was his best medicine. His coat filled in quickly... No digestive trouble and he loves it.

Sue Jenkins

We had no GI issue with our transition and both pups enjoy the food.

Susan Fischer

Our dogs love this food and having changed their food before, it is not always easy to make a transition, dogs can be picky. They had no issues with this one - they love the food!

Bernadette Fisher

Immediately started eating and gaining his weight back and ALL GI symptoms were resolved. It ended up being less expensive than me hand making everything.

Julie Hartley

Our picky Labradoodle who was prone to stomach issues... loves this food and her digestion has been completely smooth since we switched to it 100%. Plus, I feel really good supporting any ButcherBox product.

Jennifer Wargo

Only took a week to integrate with and replace his current food. It might be a coincidence but he has had a week of continuous good days. The last two days, we were able to cut his gabepentin from twice a day doses to just one and he’s still slept 5-7 hours interrupted at night for the last 3 nights!

Patricia Evans

The Importance of Hydration

Proper hydration is essential for a successful transition to new food, as it helps with digestion and nutrient absorption. When dogs are well-hydrated, they’re less likely to experience common digestive issues, which makes the transition smoother for their stomach—and your daily routine.

Benefits of Hydration and Toppers Like Chicken & Quinoa:

• Helps prevent constipation by adding extra moisture to the food.
• Reduces the chances of bloating and discomfort, which is key during food transitions.
• Supports overall digestive health, promoting smoother digestion and firmer stools.

A Special Treat to Keep Transitions Smooth and Enjoyable

This Puppy Pizza recipe is a tasty, fun way to keep your dog satisfied during their food transition. Made with Premium Nutrition Dog Food as the “crust”, our Topper as the sauce, and topped with cheese, it’s a quick, nutritious treat that adds flavor and hydration, making mealtime enjoyable and the transition easier for both of you!

Say Good-bye to messy cleanups

Switching properly to Premium Nutrition means cleaner, easier pickups—no more dreading those walks in the park!